Prince Hall himself was born in 1738 either in America or Barbados, Boston Massachusetts or Bridgetown respectively. The documents which would definitively close the discussions around this subject have not been found or are no longer available to those wishing to ascertain the facts.
Be that as it may, what we do know is that a man called Prince Hall and 14 other men who were in Boston sometime in March 1775 petitioned an Irish Registry Lodge No. 441 which was attached to the 38th British Foot Infantry stationed in Boston at that time.